What an SEO Audit Actually Checks
A useful SEO audit documents scope, evidence, uncertainty, and priorities—not just a score. Here are the eight modules a defensible audit should cover.

A useful SEO audit does more than produce a score. It establishes what was measured, identifies which findings are confirmed versus heuristic, connects the evidence to business priorities, and leaves a reproducible baseline for checking whether implementation worked. The modules below are the core of MOAI’s current audit process; exact scope depends on the site and the data access available.
1. Crawlability, indexability, and canonical signals
The audit checks whether important URLs return successful responses, whether robots.txt or meta directives block access, whether canonical tags point to the intended page, and whether XML sitemaps match the live site. These checks establish eligibility; they do not guarantee that Google will index or rank a page.
2. Google Search Console evidence
When access is available, Search Analytics shows the queries and pages that received clicks or impressions during a defined date range. URL Inspection reports Google’s current coverage evidence for individual URLs. A page can be technically indexable in a browser and still be unknown to Google, so both rendered checks and Google’s own data matter.
3. Core Web Vitals and page performance
The current Core Web Vitals are Largest Contentful Paint, Interaction to Next Paint, and Cumulative Layout Shift. The “good” thresholds are LCP at or below 2.5 seconds, INP at or below 200 milliseconds, and CLS at or below 0.1, evaluated at the 75th percentile. Values above those targets are not automatically a “ranking penalty,” and a perfect lab score does not guarantee rankings. Field data and lab diagnostics answer different questions and should be labeled separately.
4. Search presentation and on-page clarity
Titles, descriptions, headings, visible copy, image alternatives, and internal links are reviewed for accuracy and usefulness. A title-length warning is editorial guidance, not proof that Google will truncate or rewrite the title. The audit should show the observed title and explain why a change may improve clarity for a specific page or query.
5. Structured data
Structured data gives search engines standardized clues about page content and can make a page eligible for supported rich-result features. The audit checks validity, required properties, URL consistency, entity references, and whether the markup matches visible content. It does not claim that schema guarantees rankings or AI citations; Google explicitly says no special schema is required for its generative AI features.
6. Local business evidence
For businesses serving a local market, the audit reviews the completeness and consistency of the website and Google Business Profile information that is available. Google says local ranking is mainly based on relevance, distance, and prominence. A business can improve accuracy, relevance, reviews, links, and supporting content, but it cannot purchase or request a better local ranking.
7. Accessibility and user journeys
Automated checks can identify issues such as missing names, color contrast, invalid ARIA, and heading problems. They do not establish WCAG conformance. Important forms, navigation, keyboard behavior, mobile layouts, and screen-reader journeys still require manual testing.
8. Analytics and conversion measurement
If analytics access is in scope, the audit verifies whether important visits and conversion events are measurable. Search impressions without qualified visits, calls, form submissions, or sales do not show business impact. If analytics is not connected, that limitation belongs in the report rather than being filled with estimates.
What a defensible deliverable includes
- A dated scope and methodology.
- Observed evidence for every confirmed finding.
- Clear labels for objective checks, heuristics, manual review, and unavailable data.
- Priorities based on severity, reach, page importance, search opportunity, and implementation effort.
- A comparison baseline so the next audit can separate resolved, persistent, and new findings.
- Plain-language limitations and no ranking guarantees.
MOAI’s current audit packages and deliverables are maintained on the SEO Audits service page. Keeping offer details there avoids publishing stale prices or scope in an evergreen guide.
